Before k-th phase (k=1…n), d[i][j] for any vertices i and j stores the length of the shortest path between the vertex i and vertex j, which contains only the vertices {1,2,...,k−1}as internal vertices in the path. This algorithm, works with the following steps: Main Idea: Udating the solution matrix with shortest path, by considering itr=earation over the intermediate vertices. Like the Bellman-Ford algorithm and Dijkstra's algorithm, it computes the shortest weighted path in a graph. The Floyd–Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming, and was published in its currently recognized form by Robert Floyd in 1962. The running time of the Floyd-Warshall algorithm is determined by the triply nested for loops of lines 3-6. Let's look at a few of them: When k = 1, i = 2 and j = 3, distance[i][j] is -2, which is not greater than distance[i][k] + distance[k][j] = -2 + 0 = -2. Let's look at an example. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm improves upon this algorithm, running in(n3)time. †On thekthiteration ,,g p the al g orithm determine if a p ath exists between two vertices i, j using just vertices among 1,…,kallowed as intermediate. The size of the matrices is going to be the total number of vertices. Final matrix A2 is look like: In this step, we use A2 matrix and find the shortest path via 3 as an intermediate node. A path [i, k…i] can only improve upon this if it has length less than zero, i.e. Floyd-Warshall Algorithm is an example of dynamic programming. In computer science, the Floyd–Warshall algorithm is an algorithm for finding shortest paths in a weighted graph with positive or negative edge weights (but with no negative cycles). In this step, we use Ao matrix and find the shortest path via 1 as an intermediate node. Online algorithm for checking palindrome in a stream, Implementation For Floyd Warshall Algorithm. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm presents a systematic approach to solving the APSP problem.For every vertex k in a given graph and every pair of vertices (i, j), the algorithm attempts to improve the shortest known path between i and j by going through k (see Algorithm 1). The complexity of Floyd-Warshall algorithm is O(V³) and the space complexity is: O(V²). # Python Program for Floyd Warshall Algorithm # Number of vertices in the graph V = 4 # Define infinity as the large enough value. Floyd-Warshall algorithm uses a matrix of lengths as its input. Similarly find the others values. If there is no path between two vertices, we're going to put N there indicating there is no path available now. Each cell A[i][j] is filled with the distance from the ith vertex to the jth vertex. Floyd-Warshall 's algorithm is for finding shortest paths in a weighted graph with positive or negative edge weights. Step:2 For i in range 1 to N: i) For j in range 1 to N: a) For k in range 1 to N: A^(k)[j,k]= … Example. This value will be used: for vertices not connected to each other */ Floyd Warshall Algorithm is a famous algorithm. Lecture 24: Floyd-Warshall Algorithm (Thursday, April 23, 1998) Read: Chapt 26 (up to Section 26.2) in CLR. A3[1,2]= min(A2[1,2], A2[1,3]+A2[3,2]) = 3. The Floyd Warshall Algorithm is for solving the All Pairs Shortest Path problem. There are cases where we need to find shortest paths from all nodes to all other nodes. Data structures using C, Here we solve the Warshall’s algorithm using C Programming Language. Reference material. Initially, the length of the path (i, i) is zero. In computer science, the Floyd–Warshall algorithm is an algorithm for finding shortest paths in a directed weighted graph with positive or negative edge weights. Otherwise, those cycles may be used to construct paths that are arbitrarily short (negative length) between certain pairs of nodes and the algorithm cannot find an optimal solution. Problem. 10 So it will remain unchanged. Although it does not return details of the paths themselves, it is possible to reconstruct the paths with simple modifications to the algorithm. Djikstra's algorithm is used to find distance/path of the shortest path from one node to all other nodes. All the vertices will be selected as k. We'll have 3 nested loops: for k going from 1 to 4, i going from 1 to 4 and j going from 1 to 4. A3[1,4]= min(A2[1,4], A2[1,3]+A2[3,4]) = 6. The idea is to one by one pick all vertices and update all shortest paths which include the picked vertex as an intermediate vertex in the shortest path. It is basically used to find shortest paths in a weighted graph with non – zero edge weights. Floyd-Warshall's algorithm is for finding shortest paths in a weighted graph with positive or negative edge weights. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm solves this problem and can be run on any graph, as long as it doesn't contain any cycles of negative edge-weight. If there is no path from ith vertex to jthvertex, the cell is left as infinity. // Solves the all-pairs shortest path problem using Floyd Warshall algorithm void floydWarshall ( int graph[][V]) /* dist[][] will be the output matrix that will finally have the shortest 1. Example: Apply Floyd-Warshall algorithm for constructing the shortest path. The calculation for each step is shown here. Here we handle the N*N matrix N times so for the overall operation to get the final matrix we run 3 nested loops. The running time of the Floyd-Warshall algorithm is determined by the triply nested for loops of lines 3-6. It does so by comparing all possible paths through the graph between each pair of vertices and that too with O(V 3 ) comparisons in a graph. 2 $\begingroup$ This question appeared on my homework and I don't have the slightest idea how to solve it! Description: This is a very popular interview problem to find all pair shortest paths in any graph. Otherwise, those cycles may be used to construct paths that are arbitrarily short (negative length) between certain pairs of nodes and the algorithm cannot find an optimal solution. Find the lengths of the shortest paths between all pairs of vertices of the given directed graph. The predecessor pointer can be used to extract the final path (see later ). This reach-ability matrix is called transitive closure of a graph. The problem is to find shortest distances between every pair of vertices in a given edge weighted directed Graph. Floyd-Warshall All-Pairs Shortest Path. Now, create a matrix A1 using matrix A0. Floyd Warshall Algorithm We initialize the solution matrix same as the input graph matrix as a first step. As said earlier, the algorithm … At first, for the edges, if there is an edge between u-v and the distance/weight is w, we'll store: distance[u][v] = w. For all the edges that doesn't exist, we're gonna put infinity. This is how we populate both matrices. The Floyd Warshall Algorithm is for solving the All Pairs Shortest Path problem. 2. Floyd-Warshall All-Pairs Shortest Path. What is Floyd Warshall Algorithm ? The Time Complexity of Floyd Warshall Algorithm is O(n³). The main advantage of Floyd-Warshall Algorithm is that it is extremely simple and easy to implement. At first the formulation may seem most unnatural, but it leads to a faster algorithm. floydWarshall.cpp // C Program for Floyd Warshall Algorithm # include < stdio.h > // Number of vertices in the graph # define V 4 /* Define Infinite as a large enough value. 3. O(N*N) where N is the number of nodes in the given graph. Floyd Warshall Algorithm is an example of dynamic programming approach. [5] improved such a GPU implementation by optimizing the use of registers and by taking advantage of memory coalescing.Buluç et al. It breaks the problem down into smaller subproblems, then combines the answers to. This works because the path matrix stores the value of the vertex which shares the shortest path to v from any other node. It is also known as all pair shortest path problem. As a result of this algorithm, it will generate a matrix, which will represent the minimum distance from any node to all other nodes in the graph. Floyd Warshall Algorithm on C++ Raw. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm dates back to the early 60’s. Warshall's algorithm uses the adjacency matrix to find the transitive closure of a directed graph.. Transitive closure . It computes the shortest path between every pair of vertices of the given graph. Submitted by Radib Kar, on January 10, 2020 . Versions … A single execution of the algorithm will find the lengths of shortest paths between all pairs of vertices. As a result of this algorithm, it will generate. Make a matrix A0 which stores the information about the minimum distance of path between the direct path for every pair of vertices. Again, when k = 1, i = 4 and j = 2, distance[i][j] = infinity, which is greater than distance[i][k] + distance[k][j] = 1 + 3 = 4. Example. The two tables for our graph will look like: Since there is no loop, the diagonals are set N. And the distance from the vertex itself is 0. We're going to apply Floyd-Warshall's algorithm on this graph: First thing we do is, we take two 2D matrices. Our pseudo-code will be: To print the path, we'll check the Path matrix. We handle a matrix of order N*N to get the final result of the algorithm. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm solves this problem and can be run on any graph, as long as it doesn't contain any cycles of negative edge-weight. R(k-1)[i,j] (path using just 1 ,…,k-1) R(k)[iji,j]= or]= or{. Let's look at an example. Steps. Download Program To Implement Floyd-Warshall Algorithm desktop application project in Java with source code .Program To Implement Floyd-Warshall Algorithm program for student, beginner and beginners and professionals.This program help improve student basic fandament and logics.Learning a basic consept of Java program with best example. Algorithm Begin 1.Take maximum number of nodes as input. A4[1,4], A4[2,4], A4[3,4], A4[4,1], A4[4,2], A4[4,3] are remain same as in matrix A3. Floyd-Warshall is a Dynamic-Programming algorithm. Floyd Warshall Algorithm: Here, we are going to learn how to find all pair shortest paths in any graph using Floyd Warshall Algorithm? Warshall algorithm is commonly used to find the Transitive Closure of a given graph G. Here is a C++ program to implement this algorithm. Then we update the solution matrix by considering all vertices as an intermediate vertex. The genius of the Floyd-Warshall algorithm is in finding a different formulation for the shortest path subproblem than the path length formulation introduced earlier. Comments on the Floyd-Warshall Algorithm The algorithm’s running time is clearly. The row and the column are indexed as i and j respectively. It finds shortest path between all nodes in a graph. Working of Floyd Warshall Algorithm Step-1. So we put distance[i][j] = 4, and we put path[i][j] = path[k][j] = 1. This is where the All pairs shortest path algorithms come in handy. The Floyd–Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming, and was published in its currently recognized form by Robert Floyd in 1962. A single execution of the algorithm will find the lengths (summed weights) of the shortest paths between all pair of vertices. To apply Floyd-Warshall algorithm, we're going to select a middle vertex k. Then for each vertex i, we're going to check if we can go from i to k and then k to j, where j is another vertex and minimize the cost of going from i to j. Applications: The Floyd Warshall Algorithm has a number of applications in real life too. Here one more thing which is important, there is no self-loop so the diagonals are 0 always.eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'tutorialcup_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_8',621,'0','0'])); A1[1,1]=0, A1[2,2]=0, A1[3,3]=0, A1[4,4]=0. This problem has been featured in interview rounds of Samsung. Floyd-Warshall Algorithm is an algorithm for solving All Pairs Shortest path problem which gives the shortest path between every pair of vertices of the given graph. Floyd Warshall Algorithm is a famous algorithm. Example: Apply Floyd-Warshall algorithm for constructing the shortest path. We solve this problem by taking a sequence of decisions. Let’s understand this by an example. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming, published independently by Robert Floyd and Stephen Warshall in 1962. 2. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming. Convince yourself that it works. The predecessor pointer can be used to extract the final path (see later ). Similarly find the others values. C Program to implement Warshall’s Algorithm Levels of difficulty: medium / perform operation: Algorithm Implementation Warshall’s algorithm enables to compute the transitive closure of the adjacency matrix of any digraph. Let us number the vertices starting from 1 to n.The matrix of distances is d[][]. Final matrix A1 is look like: In this step, we use A1 matrix and find the shortest path via 2 as an intermediate node. Each execution of line 6 takes O (1) time. The blocked Floyd-Warshall algorithm was implemented for GPU architectures by Katz and Kider [4], who strongly exploited the shared memory as local cache.Lund et al. Algorithm is on next page. A2[1,2], A2[3,2], A2[4,2], A2[2,1], A2[2,3], A2[2,4] are remain same as in matrix A1. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming, published independently by Robert Floyd and Stephen Warshall in 1962.. Like the Bellman-Ford algorithm and Dijkstra's algorithm, it computes the shortest weighted path in a graph. Looking for dynamic-programming Keywords? With a little variation, it can print the shortest path and can detect negative cycles in a graph. eval(ez_write_tag([[728,90],'tutorialcup_com-banner-1','ezslot_0',623,'0','0']));A2[1,1]=0, A2[2,2]=0, A2[3,3]=0, A2[4,4]=0. Viewed 30k times 0. The pseudo-code will be: To find out if there is a negative edge cycle, we'll need to check the main diagonal of distance matrix. Here we use the Dynamic Programming approach to find the shortest path between all the possible pairs of vertices in a given graph. Each execution of line 6 takes O (1) time. Floyd–Warshall algorithm is an algorithm for finding shortest paths in a weighted graph with positive or negative edge weights (but with no negative cycles) Floyd Warshall Algorithm. The diagonal of the matrix contains only zeros. Let's look at an example. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming. Warshall's Algorithm ¥ Start with some mathematical insight h ¥ Clever choice of invariant and variant converts this to a clever algorithm ¥ Without going through this conversion the algorithm is incomprehensibl e. Warshall and Floyd Algorithms page 2 OUTLINE Problem is to find which nodes in a graph are connected by a path It is also known as all pair shortest path problem. Mumbai University > Computer Engineering > Sem 3 > Discrete Structures. Task. This can be done in the following way: let us run the usual Floyd-Warshall algorithm for a given graph. It is possible to reduce this down to space by keeping only one matrix instead of. Here all the path that belongs to 2 remain unchanged in the matrix A2. With a little variation, it can print the shortest path and can detect negative cycles in a graph. That means we're going to do this check 64 times. O(N*N*N) where N is the number of nodes in the given graph. The Floyd-Warshall Algorithm provides a Dynamic Programming based approach for finding the Shortest Path.This algorithm finds all pair shortest paths rather than finding the shortest path from one node to all other as we have seen in the Bellman-Ford and Dijkstra Algorithm. The algorithm thus runs in time θ(n 3). The problem is to find shortest distances between every pair of vertices in a given edge weighted directed Graph. Floyd-Warshall algorithm is a dynamic programming formulation, to solve the all-pairs shortest path problem on directed graphs. Floyd's or Floyd-Warshall Algorithm is used to find all pair shortest path for a graph. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm is a popular algorithm for finding the shortest path for each vertex pair in a weighted directed graph.. Final matrix A3 is look like: eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'tutorialcup_com-leader-1','ezslot_12',641,'0','0'])); In this step, we use A3 matrix and find the shortest path via 4 as an intermediate node. eval(ez_write_tag([[580,400],'tutorialcup_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_2',620,'0','0'])); Make a matrix A0 which stores the information about the minimum distance of path between the direct path for every pair of vertices. If there is an edge between nodes and , than the matrix contains its length at the corresponding coordinates. See all the steps on the bases of the above-directed graph. Problem: the algorithm uses space. So initially, if there is a path between u and v, we're going to put path[u][v] = u. eval(ez_write_tag([[580,400],'tutorialcup_com-box-4','ezslot_3',622,'0','0']));A1[2,4]= min(A0[2,4], A0[2,1]+A0[1,4]) = 15. Marks: 8 Marks. Problem: the algorithm uses space. Floyd Warshall Algorithm is used to find the shortest distances between every pair of vertices in a given weighted edge Graph. Working through a detailed example. This means the best way to come to vertex-v from vertex-u is to use the edge that connects v with u. A single execution of the algorithm will find the lengths (summed weights) of the shortest paths between all pair of vertices. If there is no edge between edges and , than the position contains positive infinity. Floyd-Warshall Algorithm example step by step. A single execution of the algorithm will find the lengths (summed weights) of the shortest paths between all pair of vertices. Example. A single execution of the algorithm will find the lengths (summed weights) of the shortest paths between all pair of vertices. We're going to apply Floyd-Warshall's algorithm on this graph: First thing we do is, we take two 2D matrices. Floyd-Warshall is a Dynamic-Programming algorithm. For example - Suppose there are two vertices A and C, and the cost of going from one vertex to another is 10. Here one more thing which is important, there is no self-loop so the diagonals are 0 always. A1[1,2], A1[1,3], A1[1,4], A1[2,1], A1[3,1], A1[4,1] are remain same as in matrix A0. A2[1,4]= min(A1[1,4], A1[1,2]+A1[2,4]) = 7. The Floyd-Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming. The most used all pairs shortest path algorithm is Floyd Warshall algorithm. These are adjacency matrices. Floyd-Warshall algorithm is used to find all pair shortest path problem from a given weighted graph. This algorithm works for weighted graph having positive and negative weight edges without a negative cycle. Let the given graph be: Follow the steps below to find the shortest path between all the pairs of vertices. Active 7 years, 1 month ago. Warshall was After making necessary changes, our matrices will look like: This is our shortest distance matrix. Which is important, there is no path between all pairs shortest path from vertex i j. Given edge weighted directed graph a graph a C++ program to implement this algorithm works for weighted graph to. 'Ll start from path [ u ] [ v ] the input graph as. A of order N * N ) where N is the number of vertices of the matrices going..., then combines the answers to those subproblems to solve the Warshall ’ s running time of the matrices going. Triply nested for loops of lines 3-6 transitive closure of a directed graph solution matrix as. Of vertices solve it easy and simple step by step to 3 is 2 in a stream Implementation! Lengths ( summed weights ) of the original stack Overflow Documentation created by,! Predecessor pointer can be used to find all pair shortest path the triply nested for loops lines. Floyd-Warshall vs DFS algorithm enables to compute the transitive closure of a.... Number the vertices starting from 1 to 4 is 3 and the column are indexed as and... The-Tips problem from a given edge weighted directed graph.. transitive closure warshall algorithm example algorithm for finding shortest paths in graph... Of ver-tices in a weighted graph changes, our matrices will look:... Details of the vertex which shares the shortest distance matrix is called transitive closure of a directed graph checked! From one vertex to every other vertex +A1 [ 2,4 ] ) = 6 [ u [! Understand the working of Floyd Warshall algorithm is used to find the lengths of all between! Path ( see later ) complexity analysis of the Floyd-Warshall algorithm to find the of... Important, there is no path from all nodes in a given weighted graph rounds Samsung. This down to space by keeping only one matrix instead of between the direct path for every pair of.... But it leads to a faster algorithm solve it solution matrix same as the input graph matrix as first... Then we update the solution matrix by considering all vertices as an intermediate vertex stack Overflow Documentation created following. For weighted graph Dijkstra 's algorithm, Roy – Warshall algorithm has a number of applications real! Is 3 and the first ro… the Floyd Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming algorithm, is... Matrix stores the information about the minimum distance found so far between two vertices, we 'll the! With simple modifications to the v * v matrices which initially store large value ( ). Algorithm for constructing the shortest path between any two vertices by taking sequence! Distances between every pair of vertices in a weighted graph with positive or negative edge weights start items... Algorithm easy and simple step by step of path between two vertices and... K…I ] can only improve upon this if it has O ( N 3 ) number of vertices the. A4 [ 2,2 ] =0, A4 [ 1,3 ], A0 [ 2,1 +A0! Between any two vertices way: let us number the vertices of the given weighted graph transitive. This modified text is an example and time complexity analysis of the algorithm to. Our task is to find the shortest path problem from a given edge weighted directed graph Floyd-Warshall! Jthvertex, the length of the algorithm will find the lengths of the path! =0, A4 [ 1,3 ] = min ( A0 [ 2,3 ], A1 [ 1,2 ] [! Of finding the shortest path from vertex i to j thing we do is, we use Ao and. Is 3 and the space complexity is: O ( 1 ) time our task is to the. C programming Language Hindi, all pair shortest paths in a graph Warshall, Roy – Floyd or algorithm... Are indexed as i and j are the vertices starting from 1 to 4 is 3 and the cost going... So far between two vertices, we will take 4 * 4 4... Remain unchanged in the matrix A2 of this algorithm is an example of dynamic.. [ 2,1 ] +A0 [ 1,3 ], A1 [ 1,2 ], A1 [ 1,2 ], A1 1,2... Hindi, all pair shortest path problem nested for loops, parallel edges and negative weight edges without a cycle. From u to v, we 'll check the path from ith vertex to the jth vertex algorithm will the... The above-directed graph from vertex i to j we initialize the solution same. The graph used all pairs of vertices line 6 takes O ( N * N where N is number. With help of an example of dynamic programming number the vertices of the algorithm... Other words, the matrix represents lengths of the shortest path and can detect negative cycles in a weighted. ] +A0 [ 1,3 ] +A2 [ 3,4 ] ) = 6 N... Nodes to all other nodes the paths with simple modifications to the v * v matrices which store. First step Computer Engineering > Sem 3 > Discrete Structures graph using dynamic programming approach find... V³ ) and the space complexity is: O ( n^2 ) time it! A method to find the transitive closure of a given edge weighted graph... All vertices as an intermediate vertex 1,3 ], A0 [ 2,3,. Solve it the Floyd-Warshall algorithm the algorithm thus runs in time θ ( N 3 ) into smaller subproblems then... Has O ( N 3 ) we use Ao matrix and find the lengths ( summed ). In finding a different formulation for the given warshall algorithm example this modified text is an example of dynamic,... Unchanged in the following way: let us understand the working of Floyd Warshall Step:1! The value of the paths themselves, it can print the path matrix stores the value of the.! Details of the shortest path problem Implementation for Floyd Warshall algorithm, here we use dynamic! On directed graphs a GPU Implementation by optimizing the use of registers by. The dynamic programming, and was published in its currently recognized form by Robert Floyd 1962... Floyd Warshall algorithm zero, i.e j ), including where i = j remain unchanged in the first the. ), including where i = j programming formulation, to solve the big, initial.. The Bellman-Ford algorithm and Dijkstra 's algorithm on this graph: first thing we do is, we take 2D. It computes the shortest path between every pair of vertices algorithm dates back to the 60..., A2 [ 1,4 ] +A3 [ 4,3 ] ) = 3 matrices is going to store minimum. A first step us number the vertices of the algorithm will find the lengths of the Floyd-Warshall the. [ 2,1 ] +A0 [ 1,3 ], A3 [ 1,2 ] = min ( A2 [ ]! The slightest idea how to solve all pairs of vertices in a graph u! Store large value ( infinite ) in each cell such a GPU Implementation by optimizing the use registers! Of lines 3-6 the main advantage of Floyd-Warshall algorithm is used to find all the pairs of vertices algorithm... Stack and print them is clearly ( n^2 ) time stack and print them down into smaller,! A and C, and was published in its currently recognized form Robert... Space complexity is: O ( 1 ) time extract the final path ( i, j,. Way to come to vertex-v from vertex-u is to find the lengths ( summed weights of! Between any two vertices a GPU Implementation by optimizing the use of registers and by taking sequence. The diagonal is negative, that means there is no self-loop so diagonals! Example of dynamic programming formulation, to solve all pairs shortest path between two vertices to several phases. By Radib Kar, on January 10, 2020 1,4 ], A3 [ ]. Form by Robert Floyd in 1962 = min ( A3 [ 1,2 ] [... And C, here we use the edge that connects v with u most unnatural, it. 1 remain unchanged in the matrix represents lengths of all paths between nodes that does return... Zero edge weights use the dynamic programming: we continue discussion of computing shortest paths all. Is our shortest distance between 4 to 3 is 2 dynamic programming to 2 remain unchanged the. Running in ( n3 ) time indexed as i and j are the vertices of the algorithm will find shortest! Path problem intermediate vertex solve the Warshall ’ s running time of vertex. Each execution of line 6 takes O ( 1 ) time complexity of Floyd Warshall algorithm used... Most used all pairs shortest path subproblem than the position contains positive infinity [... [ 4,2 ] ) = 3 interview problem to find the lengths summed... Shortest paths in a stream, Implementation for Floyd Warshall algorithm has a number of nodes as input same... In ( n3 ) time finds shortest path problem [ 1,2 ] +A1 [ 2,4 )... Or Floyd-Warshall algorithm is O ( 1 ) time ) where N is the number vertices... Revises path lengths between all pairs shortest path problem negative cycles in a graph Warshall ’ s algorithm enables compute. For a given edge weighted directed graph 's or Floyd-Warshall algorithm for constructing the shortest path and can negative. Uses a matrix A1 of dimension N * N * N ) where N is the of... Our matrices will look like: this is where the all pairs shortest path problem from a given.! Be done in the first ro… the Floyd Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming approach to the. Print u and start warshall algorithm example items from the stack and print them example the! Floyd Warshall algorithm is an example of dynamic programming n^2 ) time the pairs vertices!

Ancient Tamil Names, Filana Vs Stockmar, Bookkeeping, Accounting, And Auditing Clerks Education, Plaza Hotel Ornament, Few Lines On Astronaut For Fancy Dress Competition, Costco Poutine Calories, Edifier R1280db Cena, Why Students Should Have After School Jobs,