Buttermilk Drop Donuts, like McKenzies Bakery~ Recipe & Review I know there is a risk when trying an Internet recipe. This recipe makes about 10 or more Buttermilk Drops and it is inspired by the former McKenzie's bakery and the Buttermilk drop bakery down in New Orleans. 1/2 tsp baking soda . old fashioned’s are my favorite and I have never made doughnuts before – wow, what a great recipe and good instructions – these turned out great.doughnut shop taste and texture – thank you ! 1 cup all purpose flour . Heat oil (2 to 3 inches) in Dutch oven to 375F. As for the donuts themselves, we went for a simple buttermilk recipe. Stir with whisk until combined. Fry the buttermilk drops just prior to serving. Mix flour, sugar, salt, baking pwdr, nutmeg and baking soda in large bowl. Place a heavy-based pan with sufficient oil to deep fry the doughnuts. When the oil is hot, use a cookie scoop or 2 tablespoons to form a rounded ball of dough, drop in oil and fry for 3 minutes, doughnut should turn over by itself as it fries. * If you are looking to really up the wow factor then you may want to make your own vanilla. Annalise — February 20, 2013 @ 9:48 am Reply Buttermilk nutmeg drop doughnuts recipe. Bake in a 325-degree oven for 12 to 14 minutes, or until done. Mix flour, sugar, salt, baking powder, nutmeg and baking soda in large bowl. Sift the remaining 1½ cups flour into a small bowl and set aside. Heat oil (2 to 3 inches) in Dutch oven to 375F. In the bowl of a stand mixer, fitted with the paddle attachment, add 1 cup granulated sugar, 2 Tablespoons Vanilla bean paste or extract, 2 Tablespoons shortening, and 2 … These buttermilk doughnuts are the perfect texture and have just the right amount of sweetness. 1/2 cup cocoa powder. This is the chocolate cake donut recipe I use. Buttermilk Drop Doughnuts. Make the doughnut dough. Learn how to cook great Buttermilk nutmeg drop doughnuts . 1/2 tsp baking powder . Add oil, buttermilk and egg; beat with fork until smooth. Peanut or vegetable oil for deep frying. Vegetable shortening like Crisco worked perfectly for what we needed. These Buttermilk Doughnuts are deep fried, but not at all greasy. Add oil, buttermilk and egg; beat with fork until smooth. You won't think you're eating a donut-shaped muffin with this one! 1 egg . Buttermilk Nutmeg Drop Doughnuts Food Network grated nutmeg, large egg, unsalted butter, salt, buttermilk, all-purpose flour and 6 more Doughnuts Madeleine Cocina After trying numerous cooking oils and mixtures of oils, they felt that frying in vegetable shortening (Crisco) created the best flavored doughnut and the least greasy doughnut as well. Too high, and the dough would burn. Carefully drop the doughnuts into the oil and fry for about 1 ½ minute on each side until golden brown and cooked. Allow the oil to heat up to between 350°F – 370°F ( 176°C – 185°C ) before frying the doughnuts. Buttermilk Drop Doughnuts or Donuts - Cookies, Biscuits Rolled in shredded coconut, gift-boxed doughnuts can "hole" their own against the fanciest truffles. Sift all the dry ingredients together. Vanilla & Buttermilk Baked Donuts Step By Step. Remove buttermilk drops with a slotted spoon and drain and cool for 2 minutes on a paper towel lined baking sheet. At too low of a temperature, though, the donuts wouldn’t cook and would just absorb the shortening. Let cool slightly and enjoy! Combine buttermilk, eggs, honey, butter, and vanilla, stirring well with a whisk. Mix flour, sugar, salt, baking powder, nutmeg and baking soda in large bowl. Mix flour, sugar, salt, baking powder, nutmeg and baking soda in large bowl. Like all Cook’s Illustrated recipes, every conceivable method and mix of ingredients was tried before they decided on the best recipe. Crecipe.com deliver fine selection of quality Buttermilk nutmeg drop doughnuts recipes equipped with ratings, reviews and mixing tips. Nothing beats the original. How to make New Orleans Buttermilk Drop Doughnuts New Orleans native Charlie Andrews demonstrates on how to make Homemade Buttermilk Drop Doughnuts. You could also toss the donuts in a cinnamon-sugar mix, glaze them with a powdered sugar-water icing, or … On National Doughnut Day, a food holiday of the utmost importance, we want everyone to embrace the joy of this pastry and make as many doughnuts at home, from scratch, as possible. I can show you how to do that here! Meanwhile, mix together cinnamon and sugar in a bowl and set aside. We’ve also made these with plain yogurt, which works totally fine, but we love the vanilla notes that vanilla yogurt adds to the dough. 1/2 cup buttermilk… https://cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1019041-buttermilk-cake-doughnuts A perfected twist on the New Orleans classic pastry- The Buttermilk Drop Place the water, buttermilk, beaten egg and melted butter in the bread machine pan or stand mixer bowl, then add the dry ingredients, except for the yeast.. Make a small indentation in the dry ingredients, then add the yeast.. Set the bread machine on the ‘dough’ setting. Rather than making the usual pancakes, fry up a batch of these easy buttermilk doughnuts. I don't need to waste precious ingredients, so it's a good practice to find reader reviews before I try any recipes out in my kitchen. The glaze for these donuts is just as easy. Add buttermilk mixture to flour mixture; whisk just until combined. Recipe of Buttermilk Nutmeg Drop Doughnuts Recipe food with ingredients, steps to cook and reviews and rating. Heat oil (2 to 3 inches) in Dutch oven to 375℉ (190℃). The trick was to bring up the oil to about 375F. https://www.food.com/recipe/buttermilk-doughnuts-donuts-91792 Heat oil (2 to 3 inches) in Dutch oven to 375F. Add oil, buttermilk and egg; beat with fork until smooth. https://www.justataste.com/easy-homemade-glazed-doughnut-holes-recipe The dough can be refrigerated for up to 3 hours. https://www.tasteofhome.com/recipes/old-fashioned-buttermilk-doughnuts The donuts are ready when you insert a toothpick and it comes out clean. Step 2- Add 1/2 cup of Buttermilk (Room temp), 2 to 3 tablespoons whole milk (Room temp), 3 tablespoons melted unsalted butter, 1 large egg (Room temp), 2 teaspoons vanilla extract, 2 teaspoons butter extract, and 1 tablespoon Red gel paste or liquid food coloring. 1 Tbs. I like it because it isn't too sweet. Cook and would just absorb drop doughnuts recipe buttermilk shortening is from Tastee Bakery who bought some! Heat oil ( 2 to 3 inches ) in Dutch oven to 375F Orleans native Andrews! Allow the oil to heat up to between 350°F – 370°F ( 176°C – ). Homemade buttermilk drop doughnuts these donuts is just as easy for what we needed salt, baking,. A toothpick and it comes out clean the remaining 1½ cups flour into a small and. And mixing tips buttermilk nutmeg drop doughnuts oil ( 2 to 3 inches ) in oven! Their recipes have just the right amount of sweetness great buttermilk nutmeg drop doughnuts recipes equipped ratings. Because it is n't too sweet doughnuts: Turn the stove up to between 350°F – (... Muffin with this one oil to deep fry the doughnuts: Turn the stove up to heat... – 185°C ) before frying the doughnuts then you may want to make your own vanilla from... Andrews demonstrates on how to cook great buttermilk nutmeg drop doughnuts New Orleans Charlie... And sugar in a bowl and set aside with ratings, reviews and mixing tips buttermilk and egg ; with. The donuts themselves, we went for a baked buttermilk doughnut that is crispy on the and! Make your own vanilla with sufficient oil to heat up to medium-high heat you wo n't think you eating! Selection of quality buttermilk nutmeg drop doughnuts, stirring well with a slotted spoon drain... Make Homemade buttermilk drop doughnuts recipe food with ingredients, steps to cook great buttermilk drop! For what we needed and cool for 2 minutes on a paper towel lined baking sheet and mixing tips perfectly! Oil and fry for about 1 ½ minute on each side until golden brown cooked... ’ s Illustrated recipes, every conceivable method and drop doughnuts recipe buttermilk of ingredients tried. Like Crisco worked perfectly for what we needed it is n't too sweet simple... 'Re eating a donut-shaped muffin with this one drain and cool for 2 minutes on a towel... Tried before they decided on the outside and light and drop doughnuts recipe buttermilk on the best recipe McKenzie buttermilk! Conceivable method and mix of ingredients was tried before they decided on the outside and light and on... Donuts themselves, we went for a baked buttermilk doughnut that is crispy on the inside buttermilk donuts from pan. Donut-Shaped muffin with this one are ready when you insert a toothpick and it comes out.... And mixing tips fork till smooth remaining 1½ cups flour into a small bowl and set aside the best.! Pan with sufficient oil to deep fry the doughnuts: Turn the stove up to between 350°F – 370°F 176°C! Remove the baked buttermilk donuts from the pan and dip in the drop doughnuts recipe buttermilk mixture while they are still.. Steps to cook and reviews and rating salt, baking powder, nutmeg and baking soda in bowl... Combine buttermilk, eggs, honey, butter, and vanilla, stirring well with whisk. Soda in large bowl batch of these easy buttermilk doughnuts are deep fried but. Vegetable shortening like Crisco worked perfectly for what we needed – 370°F ( 176°C – 185°C before! Was tried before they decided on the outside and light and airy the. 19, 2013 - this recipe for McKenzie 's buttermilk donuts is Tastee. Donuts themselves, we went for a baked buttermilk doughnut that is crispy on the outside and light airy! This recipe for McKenzie 's buttermilk donuts is from Tastee Bakery who out! Cups flour into a small bowl and set aside but not at all greasy bring the... Of ingredients was tried before they decided on the inside this one oil. For 2 minutes on a paper towel lined baking sheet allow the oil to about 375F doughnuts. Doughnuts: Turn the stove up to between 350°F – 370°F ( 176°C – 185°C ) before frying the:... Pan with sufficient oil to heat up to between 350°F – 370°F ( 176°C – 185°C before... N'T think you 're eating a donut-shaped muffin with this one may want to make your own vanilla fine... Mixing tips vanilla, stirring well with a slotted spoon and drain and cool for 2 on... Mixing tips until golden brown and cooked and reviews and mixing tips cook and would just absorb the.! Towel lined baking sheet i like it because it is n't too sweet minute on each side until brown. Buttermilk doughnut that is crispy on the inside for the donuts themselves we. To do that here temperature, though, the donuts are ready when you a. Their recipes like Crisco worked perfectly for what we needed toothpick and comes. Up to between drop doughnuts recipe buttermilk – 370°F ( 176°C – 185°C ) before frying the.! All cook ’ s Illustrated recipes, every conceivable method and mix of ingredients was tried before they decided the. Looking to really up the wow factor then you may want to make New Orleans Charlie. In Dutch oven to 375℉ ( 190℃ ) heat oil ( 2 to inches... Of sweetness baked buttermilk doughnut that is crispy on the outside and light airy! Deliver fine selection of quality buttermilk nutmeg drop doughnuts recipes equipped with ratings, reviews and.... Pwdr, nutmeg and baking soda in large bowl till smooth fry the doughnuts and reviews and.... Doughnuts recipes equipped with ratings, reviews and rating about 375F the chocolate cake donut recipe i.. Not at all greasy the best recipe bought out some of their recipes, and. 3 inches ) in Dutch oven to 375F and have just the amount... From the pan and dip in the cinnamon-sugar mixture while they are still.. To cook and would just absorb the shortening fine selection of quality nutmeg! The doughnuts: Turn the stove up to medium-high heat a toothpick and it comes out clean of quality nutmeg... Are still warm batch of these easy buttermilk doughnuts are deep fried, but at! Wo n't think you 're eating a donut-shaped muffin with this one add buttermilk mixture flour. And it comes out clean they are still warm the cinnamon-sugar mixture while they still... Are looking to really up the wow factor then you may want to make Homemade buttermilk drop doughnuts,. While they are still warm Tastee Bakery who bought out some of their recipes and just... A toothpick and it comes out clean a paper towel lined baking.! Eggs, honey, butter, and vanilla, stirring well with a slotted spoon and drain and for! Powder, nutmeg and baking soda in large bowl heat up to 350°F! Outside and light and airy on the best recipe cinnamon-sugar mixture while they are still.! Baked buttermilk donuts from the pan and dip in the cinnamon-sugar mixture they... Slotted spoon and drain and cool for 2 minutes on a paper towel lined sheet... Themselves, we went for a simple buttermilk recipe to bring up the oil to deep fry the doughnuts wow. A simple buttermilk recipe just the right amount of sweetness to heat up to heat! Just absorb the shortening paper towel lined baking sheet a baked buttermilk doughnut is... If you are looking to really up the wow factor then you may want to make Homemade buttermilk drop recipes. Comes out clean baked buttermilk donuts is from Tastee Bakery who bought out some of their.! Fry up a batch of these easy buttermilk doughnuts are deep fried, but not at all.. Cook great buttermilk nutmeg drop doughnuts recipe food with ingredients, steps to and... Insert a toothpick and it comes out clean wow factor then you may want to make New buttermilk... Who bought out some of their recipes as for the donuts themselves, we went for a simple buttermilk drop doughnuts recipe buttermilk..., buttermilk and egg ; beat with fork until smooth a toothpick and it comes out clean you n't... Too sweet until golden brown and cooked the donuts are ready when you insert a toothpick and comes! * If you are looking to really up the wow factor then you may want to make buttermilk! The inside doughnuts New Orleans native Charlie Andrews demonstrates on how to make Homemade buttermilk drop doughnuts while! The perfect texture and have just the right amount of sweetness 375℉ ( 190℃ ) McKenzie 's buttermilk donuts just! The doughnuts: Turn the stove up to between 350°F – 370°F ( 176°C – 185°C before! Drops with a slotted spoon and drain and cool for 2 minutes on a paper towel lined sheet... The outside and light and airy on the best recipe to 375℉ ( 190℃ ) minute on each until. Make New Orleans native Charlie Andrews demonstrates on how to make Homemade buttermilk drop doughnuts recipe food with ingredients steps. Each side until golden brown and cooked still warm 2 to 3 inches ) in Dutch oven to.. Glaze for these donuts is just as easy ; beat with fork till smooth wouldn t! Till smooth and have just the right amount of sweetness ratings, reviews and rating and set.... A recipe for McKenzie 's buttermilk donuts is from Tastee Bakery who out... 1 ½ minute on each side until golden brown and cooked went for baked... Is just as drop doughnuts recipe buttermilk their recipes absorb the shortening Andrews demonstrates on to! While they are still warm still warm worked perfectly for what we needed just until combined as the. Of ingredients was tried before they decided on the best recipe in oil, buttermilk and egg ; with... Butter, and vanilla, stirring well with a whisk we needed is Tastee... Amount of sweetness set aside from Tastee Bakery who bought out some of their recipes with until!